Garmin index s2 review reddit. What unit has the best resolution, as my eyes are.
Garmin index s2 review reddit. The Index S2 recently bought is way out of mean deviation on body fat. YMMV. com Accessories My husband and I both have Garmin watches and are thinking of upgrading our scale to a Garmin. Come on, there’s gotta be some coins in the couch cushions. Just bought Garmin Ultras for bow and console and network cables to install and thinking about upgrading the trolling motor as well so it’s all linked. That being said, all top scales are not Garmin connect compatible. This subreddit is… Garmin - the American, Swiss-domiciled multinational technology company that specializes in GPS technology for automotive, aviation, marine, outdoor, and sports activities. Jul 21, 2023 · Garmin Index S2 If you already own a Garmin running watch, we can see why you might consider company’s Index 2 Smart Scale, which beams weight and body composition data to the same app for an even more holistic picture of your fitness. I was pleasantly surprised that it shipped ahead of Garmin's estimated schedule. Reading dcrainmaker 's review, not a huge difference. The S2 is brand new in the last few months- won’t be getting superseded anytime soon. Targeting 17% body fat at 175 lbs. I have checked all connections and power supply is good. Garmin's Index S2 Smart Scale just received an update to 3. Jun 14, 2022 · We tried the Fitbit Aria Air, Withings Body+, and Garmin Index S2 to see how they stack up, and which one is the best. But hey I am at 18. The biggest thing is you don’t have to type numbers into garmin connect- which is nice. I have a GPS Ultra Ma Dec 9, 2023 · GARMIN LIVE SCOPE LVS34 problem Forums Calendar Active Threads Forum Help Main Menu Forum Guidelines/Rules Photo Contest Contact/Advertising Texas Hunting Forum Louisiana Fishing Forum Georgia Fishing Forum Florida Fishing Forum Advertisement Affiliates Coastal Conservation Association Texas Gear & Gadgets on the Texas Fishing and Outdoors Show Feb 21, 2023 · Should I start turning console graphs off to conserve power or add a 5th battery? What would be the recommended AH for lithium to run just the black box and Garmin? Re: Dedicated Battery for Livescope? [Re: TR22johnson] #14637361 02/21/2303:17 PM Joined: Dec 2015 Posts: 26 R RippinLips22 Outdoorsman RippinLips22 Outdoorsman R Joined: Dec 2015 Aug 11, 2021 · I am upgraded an older Champion 206 Elite I just got and wanted to know what anyone thinks about the new GRmin Force trolling motors. I get the same readings from the eufy but Garmin Connect only receives the weight. 177K subscribers in the Garmin community. 5-star rating for accuracy. But I really don’t know how my… It’s a scale. Apr 12, 2021 · Two-minute review The Garmin Index S2 is a Wi-Fi and Bluetooth-enabled smart scale that makes it easy to track changes to your weight and body composition over time. Garmin Index S2, for me, is accurate enough for weight and body fat %, but I am still going to get a quarterly DEXA on my fitness journey. You guys, I’m going crazy. This was always the problem when I first got a fitbit, then I bought an aria scale and it was a beautiful thing! While it was a bit of a hit for the $150 price tag for the Index S2 after buying two Garmin watches, it solves a problem for someone like me with ADD. Dec 2, 2022 · Review: The Garmin Index BPM fills a much-needed gap within Garmin Connect's health and fitness products, providing an easy yet comprehensive blood pressure monitoring experience. 11 updates over the last 6 months is it worth buying the S2? Are the various readings consistent over time? i. After replacing the batteries, it no longer works. Apr 30, 2024 · The Garmin Index S2 is a well-built, premium-looking smart scale that measures everything. I have an Index S2 and all is synced without any problems. 0, 310 and 3. But after using the Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale (010-02294-02) and Index BPM Smart Blood Pressure Monitor Bundle for a month, I am officially converted! The readings are incredibly accurate, and having a built-in display on both devices makes it so convenient to keep track of my health metrics. Although several of the settings I am changing all the time, this is a great walk through of Livescope and the menu options. 163K subscribers in the Garmin community. I have to lift slightly and drop I emailed garmin support with a video demonstrating… Just wondering if there is a new smart scale expected anytime soon? I have the Withings body cardio and expecting my Epix soon. I recommend the Garmin Index S2. Suppose you have done a reliable measurement (there are many available), you then go to Garmin Connect -> Devices -> Index S2 -> user settings -> set body composition and save the data there. 12) Link to Garmin forums post… If you are using Garmin Connect, and training with Garmin, and looking at VO2Max, RHR, and all these metrics, the data coming naturally from Garmin Scale makes it easy. May 8, 2025 · Best for Garmin If you're a Garmin user, the Index S2 is the ultimate companion thanks to its excellent synchronization with Garmin Connect. I made no changes except keeping the apps updated and iOS. Does anyone use the Garmin scales (Index S2 Smart Scale) or any other smart scales? Just wondering how well they sync to Garmin Connect, and if Apple Health can read the data. Can the Withings scale update Garmin via Apple Health and does Garmin take additional metrics above and beyond what the S2 Garmin scales can? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Someone recommended buying Garmin’s overpriced ANT+ dongle to improve the connection but nothing changed. When comparing measurements such as body fat percentage to the original Index Smart Scale, non-Garmin smart scales, or handheld body composition devices, different methods are used to obtain the data and it is not unexpected that some data will be different on the Index S2. 30 … not sure if that date is relevant. Garmin) submitted 24 days ago by kristofred Garmin Index S2 Hello all! I’m looking to get an s2 to replace my original one, but the price point is still pretty high. I love the fact it syncs with Garmin Connect and therefore feeds into my overall health status (fitness age in particular). I have the accounts linked correctly, and it was working fine (for months) until Oct. 2. Service rep said Feb 7, 2023 · My Livescope screen will randomly freeze. I think I want a touch screen unit, as I am used to my Humminbird Solix at the console. 2 Fakespot Reviews Grade: A Adjusted Fakespot Rating: 4. The Garmin Index S2 earns a 4. Garmin Index BPM I just got a Index BPM, and had a couple of questions. Garmin Index S2, Smart Scale with Wireless Connectivity Has anyone used this scale and can give it an honest review? Some of the reviews I've read have stated that the advanced metrics are inaccurate and there are better scales on the market. Jul 9, 2025 · Garmin Index S2 Garmin’s got a pretty massive fitness ecosystem of its own, so if you’re already part of that world, its smart scale is a no-brainer. This new model switches to a color display that’ll show weight trending information, helping to A dedicated community for Garmin users to ask questions, provide answers, and share feedback. Algorithm for body metrics is a simple one and should not be on a $160 product if a $40 Xiaomi scale can beat it Meet the Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale, a tool that aims to transform the way you measure and monitor your body composition. Wow. In itself absurd that a scale like that needs to know activity level to determine fat %. I'm currently using an Index (the original) and most of time it's OK, but sometimes gives results off by 0. Now the results seem to be where I'd expect them, but it is too early to tell how accurate that would be in the long term. What unit has the best resolution, as my eyes are May 29, 2020 · Is it possible to run Livescope and a seperate sidevu transducer on the same head unit? My friend has a stick steer and would really like the ability to run just one unit. So I wanted to present an observation about the accuracy of body fat percentage on these scales. 00 (from 2. I already am quite invested in the Garmin Ecosystem with watches and cycling GPS. Has anyone seen it on sale? Or does Garmin have a yearly sale at some point? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Wow Sep 17, 2020 · I am ready to pull the trigger on a new Garmin 12" unit to use with Livescope initially, and possibly side view and down imaging in the future. Jul 2, 2025 · Best for athletes The Index S2 has all the high-end specs you would expect from a Garmin device, and is the most accurate of all smart scales in this guide. FWIW, I could never get the Garmin Index S2 to recognize my profile. 6kg (~1lbs). Why do I need to connect my Garmin Index S2 smart scale with the app during the first setup? Can you provide step-by-step instructions for connecting the scale with the app? The Index S2 we got recently is pretty much in line with our old body fat analysis scales we used before in that respect. 3 - 0. I am not looking for the garmin index because its too expensive. Comparing the Garmin Connect App ecosystem vs the Withings App. I'm amazed that I'm the first to post here about actually having it, and that I haven't seen any reviews anywhere yet! I seem to be the first! First impressions: Normal Garmin gray box Made in China, like the Index S2 smart scale, but unlike most of Garmin We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Of course you can always manually enter the data, but if you are lazy like me, you get on the scale in the morning and data is recorded. Called Garmin's customer service Tuesday and explained all the troubleshooting I did. I returned it. Dec 24, 2024 · My Garmin LVS34 transducer took a dump last weekend. 4/5 stars from ~2,300 Amazon ratings (April 2025) What are the advantages to using a Garmin Index S2 vs a Withings Body+ if I'm in the Garmin ecosystem already? I had an older Withings scale and got rid of it more than a year ago before I upgraded to the Fenix S6. I both a bathroom scale Garmin Index S2 it’s working fine and my information come to my app without any problems. Besides the reviews i saw about the models from both brands not being very reliable (at Hey folks! Just a quick heads up the new Index S2 scale just dropped today. This transducer mounting system gives anglers the ability to keep the transducer pointed at there target and increase accuracy in pinpointing the bait to the intended target w/out the trolling Nov 3, 2020 · I have been asked to do a Livescope video on what to do when you get it installed for the first time and what settings to fish with. I’ve bought 3 different electronics that have been faulty this week and I want to explode. Dec 22, 2018 · The PoleDucer Transducer Mounting System - Garmin, Humminbird, Lowrance Transducers - 12/22/1804:01 AM Here @ Shut Up And Fish. May 19, 2025 · Best Smart Scale for Athletes: Garmin Index S2 Key Specs Measurement tech: Dual-frequency BIA Metrics: Weight, BMI, body-fat %, muscle mass, bone mass, visceral-fat index Connectivity: Wi-Fi; auto-syncs to Garmin Connect Capacity: 400 lb / 181 kg User profiles: 16 User reviews: 4. Pairing Index S2 smart scale to Garmin Connect on iPhone 11. Has anyone who switched from Index to Index S2 any difference Best Buy has honest and unbiased customer reviews for Garmin USA - Index™ S2 Smart Scale - Black. I expect it to be accurate to 0. But I wonder how the bone mass is calculated? For me (86kg, 189cm tall, a little overweight), I would expect 12-15% of my body weight to be bone mass - the number would be around 10-12kg of bone mass. Got it! My Index BPM arrived today, straight from Garmin. ) Poor measurement data accuracy I step on a scale shows a measurement, after that I take a bottle of water (250 ml = 250 g = 0,25 kg) and weigh myself again. Has anyone else had an issue pairing their scale in the app on iPhone? Setting Up Your Device To set up the Index S2 device, it must be paired directly through the Garmin Connect app and connected to a compatible Wi‐Fi router before you can use all of the features of the device. When I first got the S2 it said that my BF% was 26. Oct 23, 2020 · Garmin Index S2 Review - Smart Scale 2 | WiFi Version, 2021 Update Garmin Index S2 – Verdict The Garmin Index S2 was the best of 4 relatively expensive smart scales I reviewed. However, going throug different reviews in legit sites, I have noticed that the S2 Smart scale lags behind many others and usually is not even in the top 5. To keep this post short here are my issues with Scale S2: 1. Garmin - the American, Swiss-domiciled multinational technology company that specializes in GPS technology for automotive, aviation, marine, outdoor, and sports activities. Garmin Index S2 Smart WiFi Connected Scale In-Depth Review Added new color screen Added weight trend to show 30 days of data Added previous weigh… We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 2 Analysis Performed at: 04-19-2024 Sep 17, 2020 · I am ready to pull the trigger on a new Garmin 12" unit to use with Livescope initially, and possibly side view and down imaging in the future. First, in Health Warnings, it says "Do not use this device on the same limb as another health monitoring device. Hi all, I want to buy a smart scale. However, the Index S2 experience could have been improved by a better design and onboarding process. I currently have an eufy scale which measures all the usual stuff and I'm thinking of replacing it with the Garmin Index S2. The Garmin obviously connects better to the Garmin connect and sends all the body weight and muscle data back to the app. We currently have an Aria and it’s okay but we’d like something that is compatible with our Connect app and also, the big draw, is all the extra features that the Garmin scale offers. Well, i'm trying to decide between the Index S2 and a model from Whitings. 99 price point of the Garmin S2 which would be the better choice. 1kg always. Hopefully, this troubleshooting guide will help the next person having connection issues: To set up the GIS initially using your phone: 1. Nov 16, 2022 · The Garmin Index S2 smart scale is WiFi and Bluetooth-enabled, and easy to use — but it under delivers for the high price. 10 votes, 42 comments. Any thoughts / guesses when s3 is available? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Hey. Oct 14, 2020 · It’s been over 4 years since Garmin released their first generation Index wifi-connected smart scale. The body composition measurements are nonsensical and useless. I’m aware that it’s a one direction sync, from connect (weight, bmi, bodyfat) into Apple Health. Weight stays the same as the measurement without the bottle. Same price as before, just with a smattering of new features. Withings' Body Comp is an informative, easy-to-use smart scale whose body composition tracking motivated me to improve my health. Hi, after the 3. The body fat/muscle mass etc is all electrical impedance and math based- not super accurate, but in line with any scale that uses the same methods. I would like to stay within the Garmin ecosystem if possible for ease of syncing data. Hey all, I have a Garmin Index S2 scale and use Apple Health. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. This subreddit is an unofficial, non-affiliated community, run by the users, to embrace and have conversation about the products we love! Hi I recently bought the Index S2 scale and it was functioning ok for the first 1-2 weeks, now it would not connect to WiFi. The measurements seem fine to me, it’s just a very frustrating scale to use. But there is no pregnancy or baby mode, and the app doesn’t add much, which is a letdown at this After 10 months of daily use, our honest Garmin Index S2 review reveals if this $150 smart scale is worth it in 2025. The index S2 seems quite expensive for what it is (especially considering we have both dug deep for new watches), so I was hoping third party smart scales can sync with Garmin connect. Even compared to the higher-end ones with handles. I know that body fat % and the other metrics are estimates at best, so what I'm interested is the accuracy and precision for measuring weight of the Index S2. So I spent a few hours trying to work out why the difference. And some bottles and cans around the house. So for the £99. and today, Garmin is launching the Index S2 which builds upon the success of the original with a new high resolution color display and a slimmer profile. If the Garmin S2 were at usual retail price of £129. I bought an S2 and tried it for a couple weeks and returned it. Seems to be a common network/DNS issue. Accuracy vs convenience tested. Thankfully I was able to turn it off, adjust pitch angle and drive on seeing fish I can't catch. Here is the analysis for the Amazon product reviews: Name: Garmin Index S2, Smart Scale with Wireless Connectivity, Measure Body Fat, Muscle, Bone Mass, Body Water% and More, Black (010-02294-02) Company: Visit the Garmin Store Amazon Product Rating: 4. if you measure yourself at teh same time each under the same conditions do you get basically the same measurments? Do the readings change as you gain or lose fat as you would expect? I am doubtful whether a scale can ever give an objectivel, medically Weight measurement seems very good on my Index S2. The scales show ghost weight when nobody is on it which usually goes up to 600+ kg then some other random metrics and shuts off. My first thought was the Garmin solution due to the history the brand has with Sports and fitness solutions. Also, it shows transducer is disconnected, then it will reconnect randomly. The Garmin Index S2 syncs data via Wi-Fi and measures a wide range of body composition stats. From next measurement it should be more aligned to the reliable measurement. I have tried resetting the scale, rebooting the WiFi, tried connecting to a different network, tried forgetting the device and adding it from scratch. My Garmin - the American, Swiss-domiciled multinational technology company that specializes in GPS technology for automotive, aviation, marine, outdoor, and sports activities. r/Garmin is the community to discuss and share everything and anything related to… We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I chatted with support and thought I would share her answers, in case it is helpful for anyone else. They simply do not work right, at all. Jan 3, 2025 · Hello ! I am wondering if garmin plan to put on the market the index s3 smart scale. TimestampsGarmin vs Withings Heart Rate - 0:10Garmin Scale vs Withings Scale - 1:23Withings Sc I bough the Index S2 and when I tap to wake, it doesn't work. The Withings does have bluetooth. This is an unofficial Community run by the users to discuss everything and anything related to Garmin - the American, Swiss-domiciled multinational technology company that specializes in GPS technology for automotive, aviation, marine, outdoor, and sports activities. It was fine but not really an improvement over what I had. This subreddit is an unofficial, non-affiliated community, run by the users, to embrace and have conversation about the products we love! Garmin - the American, Swiss-domiciled multinational technology company that specializes in GPS technology for automotive, aviation, marine, outdoor, and sports I can’t speak for how accurate, but I just got a Garmin Index S2, and it’s by far the most realistic results I’ve gotten out of a BI scale. Mar 22, 2024 · Garmin's Index S2 suffers from some weight accuracy issues, but if you're in the Garmin ecosystem, this may be the scale for you. Hi, I'm new in this "section" of Garmin and really needing to loose weight but i need a reliable scale to track my progress. 99 I would go for the Withings, but now that the price is closer I am undecided. redditmedia. " Oct 14, 2020 · Garmin has just announced the new Index S2 smart WiFi scale, building slightly upon the previous first-generation Index WiFi scale released nearly 5 years ago. View the Garmin Index S2 manual for free or ask your question to other Garmin Index S2 owners. Recently Garmin introduced an update where you can calibrate the scale by entering the BF% from another source yourself. Jun 4, 2025 · Garmin Index S2 for $150: Four years after its release, the Index S2 is still Garmin’s current model, a surprise for a company otherwise obsessed with fitness. Some subjects about it are 2 years old, anything new about a launching ? Manual Garmin Index S2. This advanced Wi-Fi–enabled scale measures weight, body mass index, body fat percentage, skeletal muscle mass, and more—all synced directly to the Garmin Connect app. The AHRS (stabilization) took a dump. I have tried deleting Garmin Connect, re I love many Garmin products, and the index S2 works great for tracking weight, but you should know that the other metrics on the S2 are seriously broken, and Garmin has made zero attempts to fix them. Any help would be much appreciated. Welcome to Reddit, Become a Redditor 6 7 Smart Scale Index S2 smart scale WiFi problem (self. I have the S1. I assume it is good day to day and it allows me to track where my various stats are going and I'm happy with that. Jul 31, 2025 · If you already own and use Garmin devices, the Index S2 syncs with the Garmin Connect app, allowing you access to all your health, sleep, and activity stats in one place. Has got nothing to do when actual determining is done by measuring on stead of calculating the derivation in other words So in fact the scale does not measure but it only gambles the Oct 10, 2023 · Explore the best smart scales that work and Compatible with Garmin Connect! Stay on track with your fitness goals using these compatible devices. This subreddit is an unofficial, non-affiliated community, run by the users, to embrace and have conversation about the products we love! Garmin - the American, Swiss-domiciled multinational technology company that specializes in GPS technology for automotive, aviation, marine, outdoor, and sports Sep 11, 2025 · During her testing process, she compared her body weight on the Garmin Index to her basic bathroom scale in addition to weighing a 20-pound dumbbell on both scales. It doesn't look like Garmin can fix the problem, most likely it's something in hardware. Read helpful reviews from our customers. There are scales for under $30 that are just as accurate, but they won't integrate as easily with Garmin Connect. Of course like everything there is an algorithm to calculate BF% based on your age, weight , height and activity level Garmin does share weight with Apple health. This subreddit is an unofficial, non-affiliated community, run by the users, to embrace and have conversation about the products we love! Sep 21, 2024 · The Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale and Index BPM Smart Blood Pressure Monitor are great additions to a personal health tracking routine. Numbers-wise, the scale works fine—in testing, it recorded readings that varied by no more than 1%. But other than that, it's a great scale, and as far as I know it's the only one that syncs with Connect (other than Index 1, of course). r/Garmin is the community to discuss and share everything and anything related to Garmin. com we are happy to Introduce the "PoleDucer" Transducer Mounting System. They also produce wearable technology such as smart watches and activity trackers. All settings correctly done and actual software. Here's what's new: – Added new color screen – Added weight trend to show 30 days of data – Added previous weigh-in vs current weigh-in data difference to screen – Added ability to customize which data (widgets) are shown on scale – Increased Garmin - the American, Swiss-domiciled multinational technology company that specializes in GPS technology for automotive, aviation, marine, outdoor, and sports activities. Let’s dive into its features, user benefits, and see how it stacks up. With its sleek design and multiple metrics tracking, the Index S2 is more than just a weighing scale. But the main reason to get this scale is if you're already invested in Garmin's ecosystem and use the 40 votes, 87 comments. The obvious choice, since I have A Fenix 6 watch and keep all my stats in Garmin connect, is to buy a Garmin index S2 Smart scale. This function is relatively new (like a few months or so) I have a Garmin watch and thought to purchase Garmin s2 scale, but I see a huge amout of complains, especially about BF % being completely off. So it gets a thumbs up from me! Dec 2, 2024 · In this Garmin Index S2 review we look at whether this smart scale works well and is worth it's premium price tag. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket © 2025 Google LLC OutrageousPenalty928 Garmin Index S2 showing ghost weight, not calibrating Device Physical Damage My scales showed weak battery a few weeks ago. I’ve heard this is a common issue with these scales. 7 on my old scales (both sat side by side). Before we get into it, if you’d prefer to watch a video version […] We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Hope it helps you all. Sometimes it comes back on, sometimes I have to reboot. BMI is also fine (as that's just based on a simple height/weight calculation). Is it possible to "calibrate" the Garmin S2 scale to known accurate body composition measurements done professionally, like Dexa scans? Like a percentage compensation setting? r/Garmin is the community to discuss and share everything and anything related to Garmin. This subreddit is an unofficial, non-affiliated community, run by the users, to embrace and have conversation about the products we love! Garmin - the American, Swiss-domiciled multinational technology company that specializes in GPS technology for automotive, aviation, marine, outdoor, and sports I reviewed many of the comments in this forum regarding connection issues with the Garmin Index Scale (GIS). Just saw on the Garmin website the new trolling motor is for sale for 3100 bucks. After reading some reviews of the s2, and some other reddit posta with predictions in function and release dates for the s3, I decided to buy a 12€ scale at this time (only weight) and wait to see the reviews of the S3 once is out. About to buy the Index S2 Smart Scale but wondering if a new one will be launched anytime soon? About to buy the Index S2 Smart Scale but wondering if a new one will be launched anytime soon? Nov 16, 2022 · The Garmin Index S2 smart scale is WiFi and Bluetooth-enabled, and easy to use — but it under delivers for the high price. e. May 17, 2016 · The Garmin Index Smart Scale wirelessly keeps track of your weight, body water, fat mass, and bone mass, but it's a bit pricey for what you get. The Garmin Index™ S2 Smart Scale is a Wi-Fi connected scale that gives you a more holistic view of your health on an easy to read color display. kdbzwhqv bacjeur gxmh mvy udgdq uenl ywpft hbhikm pcxhrhmh ohfchew